Wiadomości PRO
World

German press: Polish Constitutional Tribunal dispute warns Europe

✍ Redakcja Wiadomości PRO 📅 👁 22

Section editor: Dariusz von Prais

On November 2, 2026, the "Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung" and "Süddeutsche Zeitung" commented on the Polish Constitutional Tribunal dispute, noting the difficulty of restoring the rule of law and warning Europe to strengthen democratic institutions.
No time to read? Our AI narrator will read it to you. About 3 min.
At the end of the article: adapt this text to yourself (simpler, shorter, more detail) and ask a question about it — we answer only from this article.
German press: Polish Constitutional Tribunal dispute warns Europe
Photo: NAYEF ALENEZI / Pexels

FAZ: A "Polish dilemma" without a coup

"Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung" calls the situation in Poland a "Polish dilemma." The newspaper's Warsaw correspondent, Stefan Locke, states clearly: there has been no coup in Poland. Parliament, the government, and the president were democratically elected and remain in office. What is happening, however, is a power struggle over the Constitutional Tribunal between national-conservative and liberal forces.

Since PiS took power in 2015, the Tribunal has not been viewed as a neutral institution. The FAZ correspondent recalls that the party filled judicial positions to serve its own interests. Since 2023, Donald Tusk's government has been trying to reorganize the judiciary, but President Karol Nawrocki stands in the way. Locke assesses that by refusing to swear in legally elected judges for political reasons, the president is exceeding his authority, as the law does not grant him such a right.

FAZ does not spare the current government either. The paper considers the suspension of the Tribunal's president to be "at the very least questionable"—the president is loyal to PiS, but remains fully mentally capable. Tusk is attempting to force a decision using questionable methods as well. The commentary concludes that the rule-of-law violations from the PiS era are being addressed with further controversial legal actions, which harms legal certainty.

SZ: A "banana republic" and a warning for Europe

For Viktoria Grossmann of "Süddeutsche Zeitung," the escalation of the dispute over the Tribunal is "not only disturbing but also shameful" for Poles. In her commentary from Monday, November 2, 2026, she cites a lawyer who claims Poland is beginning to resemble a "banana republic."

Grossmann refers to the circumstances of Karol Nawrocki's entry into the Tribunal building and recordings documenting the president's behavior. She writes about his interest in boxing and his admitted hooligan past. Her conclusion: "It is difficult to build a state, especially a state based on the rule of law, with such people."

The author is skeptical about the idea of reconstituting the Tribunal with a new composition in agreement with both houses of parliament and the president. The political opponent is not interested in negotiations or power-sharing, and PiS is supported by "partially far-right and radical-right parties." This explains why PiS, during its time in power, "almost liquidated the separation of powers."

In summary, the author writes bluntly: "The complicated situation in Poland appears once again as a warning to all Europeans to strengthen their democratic institutions. It is like at the dentist – prevention protects."

Sources

Article prepared with the help of artificial intelligence based on: Business Insider Polska, WP Wiadomości, Polsat News. Facts checked automatically against these sources. The Wiadomości PRO newsroom is responsible for this publication.

Section editor: Dariusz von Prais

This text adapts to you
Have a question about this text? Ask.
We look for the answer in this article first. If it is not there, we check press sources and link them. We do not invent.

Read more in World

Comments (0)

The page is more interactive when you sign in with Google Your name is filled in automatically, and commenting is faster and safer.
Your comment will appear after the newsroom approves it.

Loading comments...

← Back
× This page adapts to you

Wiadomości PRO is a portal built from widgets — rates, reminders, quiz, weather. You choose what you see.

See widgets →
Share
Link copied