Wiadomości PRO
Poland

What lawyers say about the TK dispute: Ordo Iuris on Article 128, others on legal basis

✍ Redakcja Wiadomości PRO 📅 👁 26

Section editor: Dariusz von Prais

Ordo Iuris sees possible elements of a Criminal Code offence in the actions around Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal, other lawyers question the legal basis for removing its president, and former TK presidents back the judges elected by the Sejm. Plus reactions from abroad.
No time to read? Our AI narrator will read it to you. About 3 min.
At the end of the article: adapt this text to yourself (simpler, shorter, more detail) and ask a question about it — we answer only from this article.
Aerial view of the Supreme Court building on Krasińskich Square in Warsaw
Gmach Sądu Najwyższego przy placu Krasińskich w Warszawie, widok z drona. Fot. Kapitel / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

The dispute over who runs Poland’s Constitutional Tribunal (TK) also divides lawyers. Some ask about criminal liability for Friday’s actions around the TK, others about whether removing TK President Bogdan Święczkowski had any legal basis. Below is an overview of positions. These are opinions, not rulings: as of Sunday, November 1, there was no information that prosecutors had opened proceedings under Article 128 of the Criminal Code.

Ordo Iuris: actions “may meet the elements” of Article 128

In a statement on October 30, the Ordo Iuris institute said the actions around the TK “may meet the elements” of the offence under Article 128 § 1 of the Criminal Code (opoka.org.pl, PCh24). The provision concerns activity aimed directly at removing a constitutional organ of the Republic by force and carries a penalty of 3 to 20 years in prison. The organisation demanded that police leave the Tribunal’s seat, that the legal basis for the actions be disclosed, and that proceedings be opened under Articles 128 and 231 (abuse of power). It also appealed to the Venice Commission, EU institutions, the Council of Europe and the OSCE.

Prof. Ryszard Piotrowski takes a similar view, speaking to Wirtualna Polska of an “obvious attack on a constitutional organ of the state.” The government side rejects that characterisation. Prosecutor General Waldemar Żurek told Interia: “The coup against the Tribunal was carried out many years ago.”

Dispute over the legal basis

Prof. Marcin Matczak (University of Warsaw) told RMF FM: “This legal basis is in fact non-existent.” On Polsat News he added: “You cannot restore the rule of law by force.” He nonetheless places the main responsibility for the crisis on the president: “The president is there to look after strong institutions and the continuity of the state.”

In a round-up of opinions by TVN24, Supreme Court judge Piotr Prusinowski says that applying the provisions invoked by Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska “is highly debatable.” The head of the Polish Bar Council, Przemysław Rosati, voices “very far-reaching doubts about the legal basis.” Constitutional law scholar Dr Monika Haczkowska disagrees: “Referring to other legal acts is a normal legislative technique.” Prof. Włodzimierz Wróbel, a Supreme Court judge, notes that a temporary suspension “must be an exceptional situation” and that disputes over powers should be settled by a disciplinary court.

Former TK presidents

Four former presidents of the Tribunal, Marek Safjan, Jerzy Stępień, Bohdan Zdziennicki and Andrzej Zoll, backed the judges elected by the current Sejm in a Saturday statement: “There is no other way” to end the crisis (Interia, TVN24). Stępień said on TVN24 of the president’s night visit to the TK: “On his part it is a show of force that cannot be accepted.”

Voices from abroad

US Ambassador Tom Rose wrote on X on Friday evening: “We seem to be witnessing an unprecedented confrontation” and “I hope everyone involved will take a deep breath.” He stressed: “It is not for us to judge or interfere in its internal affairs” (Polsat News, Interia). The European Commission recalled that electing eight new TK judges falls within the Sejm’s powers and that Polish authorities must ensure the Tribunal functions in line with the constitution. According to RMF FM, former UK Prime Minister Liz Truss wrote of a “shocking blow to democracy in Poland,” while Reform UK leader Nigel Farage said “the situation in Poland is very serious.” Rzeczpospolita reports that the US government has essentially refrained from intervening.

Sources

Section editor: Dariusz von Prais

This text adapts to you
Have a question about this text? Ask.
We look for the answer in this article first. If it is not there, we check press sources and link them. We do not invent.

Read more in Poland

Comments (0)

The page is more interactive when you sign in with Google Your name is filled in automatically, and commenting is faster and safer.
Your comment will appear after the newsroom approves it.

Loading comments...

← Back
× This page adapts to you

Wiadomości PRO is a portal built from widgets — rates, reminders, quiz, weather. You choose what you see.

See widgets →
Share
Link copied