On Friday, 30 October, President Karol Nawrocki was on his way to Senegal when, in Warsaw, judges elected by the current Sejm announced the removal of the president of the Constitutional Tribunal. The plane turned back, and a few hours after landing the President was inside the Tribunal building. The two sides describe that night in contradictory ways.
Turning back over Spain
According to Wirtualna Polska, the President left Poland at around 2:50 pm. At around 6 pm, as police appeared at the Tribunal and an order suspending its president Bogdan Swieczkowski was posted on its website, the pilot told journalists on board that the aircraft was returning home (RMF24). The plane turned back over Spain.
Nawrocki wrote on X: "At such a moment the President must be in Poland. I am interrupting the flight to Senegal. I am returning." The Boeing 737 flight PLF101 became, according to Flightradar24, the most tracked flight in the world. TVP Info reported that at around 8:30 pm more than 22,000 people were following it at once, and WP counted about 1.1 million followers in total. The plane landed in Warsaw at 9:43 pm according to RMF24, before 10 pm according to Rzeczpospolita. As of Sunday no new date for the Senegal visit had been announced.
Talks at the Palace and entry into the Tribunal
After returning, the President conferred at the Presidential Palace with First President of the Supreme Court Zbigniew Kapinski and Bogdan Swieczkowski. Shortly before 1 am he entered the Tribunal building through a side entrance, together with Kapinski, the head of his Chancellery Zbigniew Bogucki and State Protection Service officers.
In the doorway there was a scuffle with a group of judges elected by the Sejm, including Anna Korwin-Piotrowska and Krystian Markiewicz. Recordings published online do not show the whole incident, and the accounts conflict.
Maciej Berek, elected to the Tribunal by the Sejm, wrote: "The President barged into Judge A. Korwin-Piotrowska and began pushing his way through the group of other judges", adding that "nobody jostled the President". Korwin-Piotrowska told TVN24 that the President "tried to ram" her.
The President's side presents the opposite version. Presidential spokesman Rafal Leskiewicz wrote that Berek had "documented the commission of a crime" and that the head of state's inviolability had been violated. Marcin Przydacz of the President's Chancellery wrote that Markiewicz and Korwin-Piotrowska "tried to jostle the President". As of Sunday, 1 November, there was no report of proceedings or charges against anyone on either side.
"You are not judges"
On a recording by Onet journalist Kamil Dziubka, Korwin-Piotrowska says: "We are judges of the Constitutional Tribunal." Nawrocki replies: "You are not judges of the Constitutional Tribunal." Bogucki tells her: "You are carrying out a coup d'etat." The President does not recognise judges who took their oath in the Sejm rather than before him. After 2 am the presidential spokesman published a photo from the Tribunal vice-president's office showing the President, Kapinski and Vice-President Bartlomiej Sochanski.
The President left the building at around 5 am. A statement was read by the head of the President's Office, Pawel Szefernaker: "Tonight the constitutional order was violated." The President called the events a "forcible takeover of a constitutional state body" and called for the withdrawal of "forces of coercion" from the Tribunal grounds.
Reactions to the night visit
Justice Minister Waldemar Zurek told TVN24: "I was greatly alarmed by the President's behaviour" and said he hoped prosecutors would act. Prime Minister Donald Tusk said in his Saturday address: "A politician may not intimidate judges, even if he is the President." Prof. Marcin Matczak, who also criticises the legal basis for sidelining the Tribunal president, was critical of the night visit and warned of "dual power" (Polsat News). PiS and Konfederacja politicians backed the President and his view that the Tribunal had been taken over by force.




Comments (0)
Loading comments...